The product I have chosen for this project is Protein Bars. I have specifically chosen Protein Bars from "The Whole Truth Foods".
A company that is focused on creating consumer trust in packaged foods. The Whole Truth Foods is a fresh face in an already established market who have made a wedge in this segment/criteria by its angular marketing and being 100% honest. #nothingtohide
Hey, does your protein bar have artificial flavors or ingredients? Do you know what Nature's identical flavors mean?
Are you worried that your healthy diet could be ruined by artificial sweeteners added to your "healthy" snack? Do you think your favorite brand is lying to you?
β
If you are still asking yourself these questions, worry not.
THE WHOLE TRUTH FOODS has got you covered!
TWTF is obsessed with being 100% honest with their customers. Their CEO, Shashank, says that, "Our purpose is simple. We make food so clean, that we can proudly declare every single ingredient that goes into it, upfront. And we can speak the whole truth because we have #nothingtohide."
β
β
India, with its ever-growing fitness culture, has witnessed a great change in the thinking mentality of people and also this has changed the focus on macronutrients consumed by people. Anybody who starts working out or is following a diet will have his/her primary focus on how much protein am I consuming on an everyday basis. As our days get busier, it gets more and more difficult for people to get the right amount of nutrients easily, which has paved the way for PROTEIN BARS in the market.
These protein bars are created as a power-packed nutritious snack that has high protein content compared to other snacking options in the market.
Protein bars have been present in the market for a long time but this industry has been dominated by the brands that have been supplementing the fitness industry. This primarily generates a problem for the consumers - they are not aware of what goes inside the bar.
To list out a few problems faced by consumers in general:
Though the consumers are aware of the nutritional value of a product, they are unaware of the ingredients of the product.
If they want to choose the right products by paying attention to the ingredients, they would have to perform the straining ordeal of going through the ingredients list on the back of products. These are conveniently mentioned in small letters.
Consumers need to comb through alternative fancy words used for some ingredients. Ex: Maltodextrin instead of Sugar.
If somebody does not know these things, then he/she would depend on their circle's fitness influencer or their gym trainer's recommendations. Recommendations from fitness industry kind of revolve around legacy fitness brands. could be based on knowledge or what the market pushes.
These problems led to the main offerings of The Whole Truth Foods
Nutritious food products with:
a. Ingredients used are mentioned upfront.
b. Nutritional facts mentioned with utmost clarity.
c. No hidden * marks.
For a busy, urban, fitness-focused individual, who wants nutrition from clean food sources, The Whole Truth Foods is a clean food company, that provides various products for nutrition from clean sources. β
β
For the sample size: Did 5 conversations with people from different parts of the country and having different fitness/dietary goals. These are generally people who work a 9-5 job or are running their businesses.
We can summarise the main points mentioned by them here:
β
Apart from the above-mentioned consumers, I also had the chance to speak with a gym fraternity and Reebok-certified trainers & nutritionists.
β
B2C Table
β
Criteria | User 1 | User 2 | User 3 | User 4 | User 5 |
Name | Himanshu Mantri | Bhargav Reddy | Aangeeras | Khyati Shah | Meikandan |
Age | Early 30s | Late 20s | 27 | 28 | 31 |
Location | Ahmedabad | Hyderabad | Chennai | Gurgaon | Pune |
Designation | Businessman | Product management | Product marketing | Product management | Runs his own business. Fitness industry expert. |
Need | Pure vegetarian so looks for clean protein sources as he strives to remain fit. | Get fit and loose fat. Mostly eats clean foods/home cooked food for his daily needs but has protein bars from time to time. | Gain muscle and play lot of sports. Eats home cooked food, has protein bars or powders from time to time to maintain his macros. | Veg food and has a very carb heavy diet. Struggles to maintain the protein intake. Wants to remain fit so does walking. Has protein bars as snack. | Maintain fitness and make his students more clean food oriented. |
Pain Point | Tried several brands to promote protein intake but has bad reactions. | Protein bars easily available have artificial content and sweetners. | Easily available protein bars are not very healthy. | Good, light source of protein. | Travels a lot for coaching and struggles to have the right amount of nutrients every time. |
Solution | Has finally settled on TWTF bars and products as they are clean. | Moved to TWTF products because of no artificial sweetners. | Loves TWTF bars as they can be ideal replacement for a meal. | Has bought protein powder to be consumed regularly. Has bars during long walks or treks. | Carries protein powders with him or carries his own homemade bars. |
Perceived Value of Brand | Only Trust TWTF and not its competitors. | Good marketing. and trustworthy | Trust worthy and honest about ingredients. | Likes the products because brand honesty. | Good taste and a clear ingredient list. On the heavier calorie-dense food side. |
Marketing Pitch | Clean healthy food | Clean and honest foods. | Big fan of Shashank and TWTF's marketing strategies. | Clean food without adulteration. | healthy snack. Should be more inclined toward fitness industry community. |
Frequency of use case | Consumes it maybe 2-3 times a week. | maybe 3-4 times in 2 weeks. | Almost 3-4 times a week. | maybe 1 or 2 in 2 weeks. | at least 5-6 bars in a week. but homemade bars so far. |
Average Spend on the Product | Doesn't mind spending if the product is good. | Doesn't consume much because its expensive but sometimes its a good alternate. | INR 80/- per bar. Is comfortable for him. | Finds protein bars too expensive. | Price is doable. |
Value Accessibility to product | He plans his meals and snacks to the availability on website of quick e-commerce is good for him. | Would have preferred for it to be available around local stores or in office vending machines. | Orders it in bulk from website so he is happy. | Buys them generally from local stores so was not even aware of TWTF until husband told her about this. | Should be available at nearby stores. |
Most used apps | Instagram, Facebook, Linkedin, swiggy instamart | Instagram, Quick commerce, LinkedIn, | Instagram, youtube, Linkedin, | Instagram, LinkedIn, youtube, quick commerce apps | Youtube, Instagram, google maps, Notepad, |
Regular expenses apart from utilities | Shopping for family, investments, EMIs | Investments, Gym membership, ordering food, body care products. | Investments, Gym membership, Supplements(Sometimes), Travel | Eating out, Shopping, Travel | Travel, Shopping, Gym membership, supplements. |
We have multiple types of consumers but we can group them in 2 sections and prioritise them:
ICP 1: Fitness enthusiast - greatly influenced by ads, marketing, and even the stories shown. This person has a 9-5 job and tries to maintain his/her fitness with minimum activities and diet. Most of their expense is focused on things related to family or house. Sometimes they make expenses in buying a gym membership or few supplements like protein powder or so.
ICP 2: Fitness experts - greatly influenced by the facts mentioned on the product. This person a fixed schedule to manage his/her fitness goals and work goals. They have fixed expenses for their house and investments along with the expenses focused on their fitness. Supplements, gym memberships or even body care products.
Criteria | ICP 1 | ICP 2 |
---|---|---|
Adoption Curve | Medium | High |
Appetite to Pay | Medium | High |
Frequency of Use Case | Low | Medium |
Distribution Potential | Low | High |
β
Factors | Yoga Bars | Ritebite Maxx protein bars | β | Competitor 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|
What is the core problem being solved by them? | Healthy breakfast and snack options | Protein supplements of every form. | ||
What are the products being offered? | Several but our focus will be on Protein bars. | Several but our focus will be on Protein bars. | ||
What channels do they use? | Online + Offline | Offline + online | ||
Brand Positioning | healthy snacking options with natural flavours. | Formulated to provide right amount of Protein with every snack. | ||
UX Evaluation and remarks. | Finds it to be dehydrating the mouth. The taste is not that great. | Finds good content of protein but then there is artificial sweeteners and ingredients. its the most easily available brand in local stores so it purchasing this is about convenience. |
Let's expand our understanding to some numbers:
For ease of our calculation, we assume that these two ICPs are concentrated in the top 10 metropolitan cities according to the 2011 census of India.
Cities | Total Population | Population between the age of 18-50 | Population with an earning potential of 9 LPA |
---|---|---|---|
Mumbaiβ | 12,44,373 | 6,389,498 | 319,475 |
Delhiβ | 11,034,555 | 4,796,598 | 239,830 |
Bengaluru | 8,443,675 | 5,203,319 | 260,166 |
Hyderabad | 6,731,790 | 3,783,187 | 189,159 |
Ahmedabad | 5,570,585 | 3,431,659 | 171,583 |
Chennai | 4,681,087 | 2,376,819 | 118,841 |
Kolkata | 4,486,679 | 2,239,959 | 111,998 |
Surat | 4,467,797 | 3,129,185 | 156,459 |
Pune | 3,124,458 | 2,082,255 | 104,112 |
Jaipur | 3,046,163 | 1,614,419 | 80,720 |
P.S: As per various reports, the Indian urban population has seen a year-on-year growth of approximately 1.4%, and the earning potential of households in metro cities has seen a year-on-year growth of 8-12%.
This would significantly increase our SOM and SAM. β
These methods clearly show that most of TWTF's consumers are either fans of Fitshit or have been influenced by content marketing.
TWTF has a great content loop and hook to get consumers hooked on what they offer.
β
β
β
Channel Name | Cost | Flexibility | Effort | Speed | Scale | Budget |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Organic | Low | High | High | High | High | Low |
Referral Program | Low | High | Low | High | Low | Low |
Product Integration | High | Low | High | Low | High | High |
Offline channel integrations | High | Low | High | Low | High | High |
β
β
Organic searches across google, quick e-commerce apps and e-commerce ads are done on 17/08/24:
For words protein bar:
β
For words like healthy Protein bar:
β
From these two simple searches that associate most the protein bars or healthy options for protein bars, it is quite clear that TWTF has been spending a lot of money to show sponsored ads on Google searches and e-commerce searches.
SEO optimization is required for words like Protein bars, healthy protein bars, and healthy snacking. This will help consumers identify where exactly TWTF stands and differentiate themselves.
They should also add the words healthy protein bar or whole foods protein bar on their description so that it's easy to for consumers to understand.
This will be the first experiment I would do, to improve the acquisition of new consumers.
Things to do to improve organic results:
β
β
β
TWTF's team plays with their content on various sources and we can categorize their content loops as shown below:
Content Loop | Hook | Generator | Distributor |
---|---|---|---|
Blog - Fitshit | Learn the basics of health, fitness, and healthy lifestyle. | TWTF's CEO and their in-house team | SEO (via Google search) Consumers share via WhatsApp or social media messengers. |
Health & wellness company that is focused on rebuilding the world's trust in its foods. | TWTF's CEO and their in-house team | Timeline and explore tab of Instagram. Consumer stories and and DMs. | |
Youtube | Tell you the whole truth of living a healthy lifestyle. | TWTF's CEO and their in-house team | Youtube discovery & timeline |
Newsletter | One, BS-free, in-depth article about food & fitness | TWTF's CEO and their in-house team | Official email to consumer's inbox. One every week |
Podcasts | Seeking the truth from those closest to it. | TWTF's CEO and their in-house team. | Discovery on Spotify & apple podcasts. |
These guys play a great game on the content side of their business as they utilize every touchpoint with their consumers via Social media or mass media.
As part of my experimentation, I would focus on doubling down on the Instagram content loop.
Why? --> This is a thing that never dies down. It always has one way or the other keeping the audience interacted.
This doesn't mean that other sources have a seasonal trend but they have a popularity trend that can move from time to time. For example: There was a peak when everybody was listening to podcasts, however, this had to be modified to video formats of podcasts which seemed to have become popular among its consumers. This makes a move from streaming audio sources to channels like YouTube. But Instagram is a medium where one can create content of different lengths, sizes, and focus. The consumption of content there has been increasing - on average a user consumes 33 minutes worth of content on Instagram.
Hook: "Health & wellness company that is focused on rebuilding the world's trust in its foods." --> This is the description of their Instagram page.
This description can be a great asset as it can be focused on not just educating people about what goes on in their food but also tell about the health problems or benefits that could come from the food they consume. This can also be used to talk about various healthy lifestyle choices and the kind of food that can supplement these choices.
This falls in line with the ultimate goal of the company - To rebuild the world's trust in its foods.
Generator: content
β
Distributor & Channels:
At this stage, the main channels to which these contents are distributed are the timeline and explore tab of Instagram.
Once discovered, they are further shared by various users via social media messaging apps or DMs on Instagram.
The content hosted on Instagram can also act as a distribution channel for other sources.
Example: A reel about the new podcasts with the IndianPharmer can be communicated and linked on Instagram so that people see a small glimpse and then move on to listen to the podcast.
We can also focus on optimizing the SEO so that these contents are discovered on Google searches with specific words or sentences.
β
This is a topic that I will not be touching upon because, from the screenshots attached on the first section, we can see that they are heavily invested in paid ads on various platforms. 80% of their revenue is generated from online sales so their paid ads are clearly working.
Besides, I am more interested in looking at things that are not yet started and their focuses.
β
TWTF being a fast-growing company that has had a great PMF, we should ideally focus on collaborating with fast-growing organizations which are related to health, fitness, or sports.
When we talk about these categories, we should ideally focus on fastest growing fitness center network in India - CULTFIT
Why Cultfit?
Cultfit is the fastest-growing chain of gym & fitness centers that set themselves apart from the traditional centers with the help of their cult fit app.
At this moment, Cultfit is focused on penetrating the metro cities market and then expanding to tier 2 cities in India. Within the top 10 metro cities (same as considered earlier) of India, cult operates approximately 327 centers.
Every single user who is going to these centers has been kept engaged via their cultfit app.
Discovery of TWTF products:
This will involve 2 types of discovery points:
a. Online discovery
b. Offline discovery
This would mean the presence of small fridges at cult centers where quick consumption products like protein bars can be placed and displayed.
We can also have small advertisements or events with Cult that can be sponsored by TWTF which will improve the discovery points for the consumers.
This integration has 2 aspects to it:
1. It becomes easy for users to buy their fitness supplements from one location and this will be a constant reminder to them as they have to open the app every time they check in at a gym.
2. You will be targeting ICP2 very clearly as awareness of such products is a primary blocking point for them.
Added integration
Instagram Store:
This will be an easy and quick integration as the user will be able to buy a product directly from the Instagram posts as and when a product will be launched.
They have 266k followers on Instagram, with the Instagram store will help every new consumer to buy the product quickly and try it.
β
Discovery points on Instagram:
ICP 2, which is being introduced to this product slowly are fitness experts who plan their weekly meals and will not be skipping meals because of any reason, so let's target ICP1.
These are mostly officegoers and people who have a 9-5 job and spend a lot of time at their desks in offices.
BB instant vending machines:
These are present in every tech park or co-working space and become the easy access point for snacks. Positioning of TWTF protein bars here has two aspects:
Local Kirana Stores:
Every consumer who is on the go and enters a local store to buy a protein bar is always greeted with MaxProtein or Yogabar. The reach of TWTF bars via local store presence is null. We are missing a huge chunk of people from this point.
We should target Kirana stores or medical stores that are close to fitness centers or sport centers or even turfs so that we have first hand exposure to our ideal customers.
Though the brand has a refer and earn page on its website, it's something that does not work or shows no information.
Their entire referral program can be considered null.
However, up until June 2023, TWTF had referral programs on their website and it was scrapped recently, which is extremely surprising.
So let's go ahead and design a new simple referral program for them.
The program:
β
β
β
β
Brand focused courses
Great brands aren't built on clicks. They're built on trust. Craft narratives that resonate, campaigns that stand out, and brands that last.
All courses
Master every lever of growth β from acquisition to retention, data to events. Pick a course, go deep, and apply it to your business right away.
Explore foundations by GrowthX
Built by Leaders From Amazon, CRED, Zepto, Hindustan Unilever, Flipkart, paytm & more
Crack a new job or a promotion with the Career Centre
Designed for mid-senior & leadership roles across growth, product, marketing, strategy & business
Learning Resources
Browse 500+ case studies, articles & resources the learning resources that you won't find on the internet.
Patienceβyouβre about to be impressed.